The Newsroom

International News Presentation: Past and Present

(February 2007)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
EY
the eye
TVNZ1, New Zealand; Maori-language news, 2018:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9kVf9xd-lzU


This is the first time I saw Te Karere being subtitled in English. Also the newsroom is somewhat noisy.

Is TVNZ a public broadcaster or merely a commercial broadcaster? Does TVNZ consider airing Te Karere as an obligation considering that the Maori language is one of the languages used in New Zealand? How about Maori Television?



Public broadcasting in New Zealand is very fragmented. Funding comes from the government body NZ On Air, set up in 1989, which bankrolls a lot of TV, radio, web series, and even music videos. All of these are hard to fund commercially in a small country.

Any broadcaster can apply with an idea for a show, and indeed any website can. One of the best (and only) recent NZ documentaries, The Valley, about the Afghanistan war, was a co-production of the website Stuff and TV3.

Māori Television is the only real public-service TV broadcaster just now: it's in English and Māori and shows a range of genres on a modest budget, mostly around Māori themes. It's funded by Te Māngai Pāho - like NZ On Air, but to promote Māori culture via media. This money is guaranteed by law, due to the government's historic neglect of the culture.

Its daily news show is Te Kāea:
- https://www.maoritelevision.com/tv/shows/te-kaea
*


RNZ (Radio NZ) is a trio of public stations, but RNZ has been branching into video and TV content recently. Generally it's got the most serious journalism in the country, and RNZ National is one of the country's most popular stations because of this.

Some radio programs are televised (on Freeview ch 50 or below). Mostly "radio with pictures" type stuff in John Campbell's living room, but it's a start. Smile This was the election show from 2017:

- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cnceBjlZsLI&t=29m47s
*


TVNZ is commercial but the state gets the profits - usually less than £10m a year. TVNZ could also be compared to Channel 4 schedule-wise, if C4 was having a bad day and showed 90% imports. And if its news was tabloidy and superficial. And the next show was hosted by a duller Kiwi Richard Littlejohn type giving his opinions. Confused

So, not much like C4 or the BBC. It's uncertain what TVNZ's purpose is now - it's largely similar to its commercial rival Three, as the TVNZ charter was abolished in 2011. Each channel has some publicly-funded shows with ads, like the Māori news Te Karere, but the (commercial) TVNZ 1 News got into trouble for a cackhanded survey on race, which a more diverse broadcaster would have avoided. For a 'national broadcaster', it's failing to represent a wide view of the country. I hope it'll get better (the Littlejohn guy has quit...).



Your opinions and "facts" re; tvnz amuse me a great deal.
GU
guest03
Your opinions and "facts" re; tvnz amuse me a great deal.


Please explain.
elmarko and WW Update gave kudos
S7
sbahnhof 7
Please defend tvnz with faint praise. Smile
HA
Hazimworks
So TVNZ is more like my country's RTM then.


The Television side only, yes.



Does RTM have to show a certain number of Malaysian productions? And I guess it runs ads in every program?


RTM has probably the most number of Malaysian productions. Also includes dramas and animation. However I think the programming quality is nowhere as great as other countries. In the early days of Malaysian TV (and even until the 2000s), foreign programs mostly in English dominate the programming.

Just like all other TV stations in Malaysia, RTM does run ads, but only during programs. There are a few programs that don't have ad breaks. It's also one of the sources of incomes for RTM. TV licence was also the source of income until the late 1990s.

Speaking about Charters, the only clear example I could find is their Client's Charter: https://www.rtm.gov.my/en/about-us/client-s-charter
WW
WW Update
More elegant Tegna graphics, this time from WXIA in Atlanta:

S7
sbahnhof 7
"facts" re; tvnz



Fair enough, I'm maligning them. Obviously a broadcaster called TVNZ isn't "90% imports" from outside NZ. On TVNZ 1 the imports are 60% of programs - most of the NZ content is Breakfast and the news - and Three (TV3) might soon overtake it in Kiwi content. TVNZ 2 has 87% overseas shows, and third channel Duke would be even higher. Not that these overseas shows are low-quality (they've got Jeremy Kyle!), but there's loads of good New Zealand television being made by less prominent broadcasters. It could be shown on the biggest channels, if their main motive wasn't to turn a buck.

* < Latest local content chart (NZ On Air)

- Audience profiles for TVNZ, Three and Prime
(NZ On Air)
WW
WW Update
CHRO; Ottawa, ON, Canada; 1999:

Last edited by WW Update on 19 February 2018 5:53am - 2 times in total
MO
Mouseboy33
Thanks for finding the TheNewRO newsSIxOttawa video. For those that dont know, this was CityTv's first big expansion of the Citytv CityPulse format to their stations they purchased across Canada. All of the stations were rebranded and received a format that was similar to Citytv's CityPulse. Yes it looks dated today. But there are some brilliant techniques employed that were unique and a point of difference even back then. The use of natural sound in the story packages were and still are Citytv signature technique, the videographers holding their cameras whilst being shot by another camera, IMO always looked great, the news vehicles in the back ground whilst presenting your back live on scene, the branded clipboards, cameras, jackets, etc (all great visual branding. The graphics, I've always thought was bit much. But the roving camera in the news environment (remember they were specifically not to be called studios) and the beat reporters were typically called specialists, were brilliant creative moves. Would love to see a modern take on the Citytv Citypulse format.
WO
Woodpecker
A 2015 opener to Dutch news programme Hart van Nederland, as broadcast on SBS6 (think a sort of Dutch Channel 5):



Hart van Nederland is unique in that it focuses solely on news from within the Netherlands. This is because SBS6 is a comparatively small channel, which doesn't really have the budget for international news. Anyway, Hart van Nederland is quite a curious programme IMO, with several interesting quirks: the headlines and news reports are voiced over by an announcer, rather than the presenters/reporters, respectively; it also makes heavy use of vox pops (that being something of a USP within the Netherlands), it is known for its sensationalist reporting, and it is always presented by two women. I have no idea why the latter is so - if any Dutch readers know, I would be interested to know, too.

This being said, it is a very successful programme, having been copied many times by other Dutch broadcasters, albeit with little success. At one point, the editors decided to make it into a more conventional newscast, ditching most of the quirks I mentioned above, and even hiring a male presenter, but this failed and the old format was gradually restored.

Incidentally, the theme tune to BR's Rundschau is very similar to that of Hart van Nederland - one wonders if BR took some inspiration from there... (that being said, the Rundschau theme is nicer, IMO):

Last edited by Woodpecker on 19 February 2018 10:57pm - 2 times in total
WW
WW Update
Shortly after it was established, SBS6 also aired a newscast known as Actienieuws (Action News) , which had a similar format (with two female anchors) and was modeled in part on American local newscasts of the time:



Do you know anything about its history? Apparently, it didn't last long.
WO
Woodpecker
Shortly after it was established, SBS6 also aired a newscast known as Actienieuws (Action News) , which had a similar format (with two female anchors) and was modeled in part on American local newscasts of the time:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CxdQ9-LEtIc

Do you know anything about its history? Apparently, it didn't last long.


Yes, it was SBS6's first foray into international news; that being said, from what I can gather, the stories covered were those deemed to have some relevance to 'the ordinary man or woman'. To use an example from the programme's editor, Boris Yeltsin's heart bypass would be covered, but NATO's expansion to eastern Europe would not. As always with SBS6, Actienieuws' coverage was highly sensationalist, SBS6 being a populist, downmarket channel. (SBS6 even showed soft porn late at night in its early days - remind you of a certain British channel?)

Anyway, as you say, Actienieuws didn't last very long, being axed at the start of 1999. It was revived in 2004, and did very well this time round, regularly attracting over half a million viewers. Ultimately, it proved too expensive to produce, and was again axed in 2006, being replaced with an extra edition of Hart van Nederland, which continues to this day. Clips from this second era are scarce, but I did manage to find a promotion from around 2004 for Actienieuws: (BTW, I really dig the theme tune in that clip)



BTW, I found out the reason for Hart van Nederland only ever having female presenters: the chief editor's reasoning is that "They are familiar faces and recognizable types - they could be your wife, girlfriend or mother."
Hazimworks and WW Update gave kudos
RA
radiolistener
How is the overnight situation in other countries?

In Germany the news channels only show documentaries overnight. At 6 am n-tv and Welt (N24) often broadcast a prerecorded bulletin from the previous evening (except in the case of breaking news) and at 7 both channels finally start their first news bulletins of the day.


Are there any 24/7 news radio stations in Germany?

Newer posts