TV Home Forum

BBC Oneness - idents and presentation

"Watch this space" as BBC Creative respond to ident change request (December 2016)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
BR
Brekkie
2. Retaining the globe symbol for BBC One was seen imperialistic and a relic from the days of broadcasting to the British Empire.

Only by marketing people, who felt the planet we all live on wasn't "inclusive" enough. You'd think if they really wanted to be inclusive the BBC logo wouldn't exclude 24 letters of the alphabet!
RI
Richard
The comments made about Oneness being a one year project are hardly unjustified. Searching “Martin Parr Oneness” into Google , the first three results are a blog post on the BBC Creative page referring to a “year long collaboration” and the other two are news articles both making reference to capture an evolving portrait of modern Britain “for 2017”. Whilst I suppose you can now read that as being rolled out across 2017 (despite us having seen no new idents for the latter four months), it wasn’t really naive to assume this was simply a one year stopgap as some posters are suggesting.


I personally would be surprised if this lasts the year. I would have thought something new, with the Reith font is being planned.
:-(
A former member
I’ve noticed a few trailers this week for shows where they give the day and also the date, but not the time, as if they are for something beyond the current week. They’ve been for shows over the next few days though.

Just now there was a trailer for the Miriam Margolyes show that just said Wednesday 3rd January with no time.
DA
davidhorman

2. Retaining the globe symbol for BBC One was seen imperialistic and a relic from the days of broadcasting to the British Empire.


Seen by whom? What percentage of the viewing public actually remembers the British Empire?
DE88, Stuart and dosxuk gave kudos
VM
VMPhil
I’ve noticed a few trailers this week for shows where they give the day and also the date, but not the time, as if they are for something beyond the current week. They’ve been for shows over the next few days though.

Just now there was a trailer for the Miriam Margolyes show that just said Wednesday 3rd January with no time.

Maybe the people who make the trails are still off, and so they're continuing to use the versions that are only supposed to be used long in advance.
KD
Keith Drop
I’ve noticed a few trailers this week for shows where they give the day and also the date, but not the time, as if they are for something beyond the current week. They’ve been for shows over the next few days though.

Just now there was a trailer for the Miriam Margolyes show that just said Wednesday 3rd January with no time.
Standard practice every year to use dated versions, between Christmas and New Year people lose track of what day of the week it is.
JF
JetixFann450
I really do not get why the BBC wastes all their money on these horrific "oneness" idents. They clearly do not represent the programmes and are a slap to the face to TV license payers.

If you ask me, it's ridiculous the BBC believes "that'll do" is the the last option for their presentation. BBC Two is stuck in the 90s and is as if the BBC do not want to waste their money on their presentation, even though it clearly is important for a brand or logo to be recognisable.
ST
Stuart
2. Retaining the globe symbol for BBC One was seen imperialistic and a relic from the days of broadcasting to the British Empire.

BBC One (BBC1) has never broadcast to any "empire", it has only ever been a UK channel.


By the way pres fans, this was the first appearance of the balloon, 21 years ago . .

I got up early that Saturday morning to see this . . . it wasn't just the first live action ident, but the first time the BBC had used a jingle with their ident.



I don't think anyone got up to watch "oneness" return, and if they did, I bet they went back to bed quite disappointed.
Last edited by Stuart on 2 January 2018 3:21am - 4 times in total
FO
FanOfTV99
Maybe the balloon might come back as one of my mates
2. Retaining the globe symbol for BBC One was seen imperialistic and a relic from the days of broadcasting to the British Empire.

BBC One (BBC1) has never broadcast to any "empire", it has only ever been a UK channel.


By the way pres fans, this was the first appearance of the balloon, 21 years ago . .

I got up early that Saturday morning to see this. . .

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jSylRz6KRF0

I don't think anyone got up to watch "oneness" return, and if they did, I bet they went back to bed quite disappointed.


Actually i switched over to sky one instead. My family wasn't pleased one bit but hey i did them a favour
WO
Worzel
I really do not get why the BBC wastes all their money on these horrific "oneness" idents. They clearly do not represent the programmes and are a slap to the face to TV license payers.

If you ask me, it's ridiculous the BBC believes "that'll do" is the the last option for their presentation. BBC Two is stuck in the 90s and is as if the BBC do not want to waste their money on their presentation, even though it clearly is important for a brand or logo to be recognisable.


But as has already been said, it's not just the TV channels that are suffering from tired presentation, the radio stations are as well (especially BBC Local Radio), with some stations using imaging and sonic IDs from 2008 or 2010.

I keep expecting to turn on one morning and find BBC Breakfast using titles from 1994 or BBC One reverting to something spinning round on a turntable circa 1984 to freshen things up. Laughing

But seriously, with an ever competitive market its more important than ever for TV channels to have strong brands and identities. But also the BBC have got to move on and realise they need to be attracting a younger audience who will remain loyal, pay the licence fee and watch programmes in years to come. It doesn't help that BBC One doesn't have a property of its own like BBC Two has with its '2'.

However, times have shifted - its not 1991 anymore, they can't continue to operate their channels as standalone services with a few digital add-ons bolted on here and there. Its like the BBC gets stuck in a rut - they did before the 1997 revamp and rebrand when they were pulled up to date. Really, a full overhaul is needed and is well overdue. Surely the heads of presentation can see its all a bit of a mess on the inside, can't they?
Last edited by Worzel on 2 January 2018 3:31am - 2 times in total
SW
Steve Williams
The first part nearly overran into Midnight!


There's absolutely no way it would have overrun into midnight. Even the most half-arsed village hall band knows they should stop for midnight. It was the whole point of the programme!
DP
D.Page
BBC1 NI, 10.00pm last night:

*

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

Newer posts