HO
The difference being that she was very much restricted to reading the news in her role on BBC Breakfast - she wasn't writing her own scripts, leading interviews or ad-libbing.
And I think in truth the explanation that "she isn't a trained journalist" was probably code for "she doesn't have the skills we require". That said, I think they missed a trick not moving her at the time to Radio 4, where the newsreader role is much closer to 'traditional news reading' than present roles. Moira becoming lead newsreader on Today would have been a good news story overall... And I'm not surprised Chris Evans had a similar thought a few years later.
Ben Sheppard presenting GMB is akin to Carson Daly filling in on NBC's Today Show... It's not that he's unsuitable for breakfast/morning television, just unsuitable for co-presenting such a programme. Still, he's much better in a journalistic-like role than Philip Schofield...
Interesting contrast with the outcry on this forum when Moira Stuart was taken off TV newsreading because she isn't a trained journalist.
The difference being that she was very much restricted to reading the news in her role on BBC Breakfast - she wasn't writing her own scripts, leading interviews or ad-libbing.
And I think in truth the explanation that "she isn't a trained journalist" was probably code for "she doesn't have the skills we require". That said, I think they missed a trick not moving her at the time to Radio 4, where the newsreader role is much closer to 'traditional news reading' than present roles. Moira becoming lead newsreader on Today would have been a good news story overall... And I'm not surprised Chris Evans had a similar thought a few years later.
Ben Sheppard presenting GMB is akin to Carson Daly filling in on NBC's Today Show... It's not that he's unsuitable for breakfast/morning television, just unsuitable for co-presenting such a programme. Still, he's much better in a journalistic-like role than Philip Schofield...