Indeed.
TR
There are a lot of colours in there. It's rare that you see that sharp spectrum of colours in SD, sorry if I'm wrong!
Nini posted:
What makes it HD? Anything that couldn't be done in SD? Not saying "go do something real intricate so it'll look fancy on a HD screen", just give some justification for it beyond a slightly bevelled logo.
There are a lot of colours in there. It's rare that you see that sharp spectrum of colours in SD, sorry if I'm wrong!
SA
*gasp* a positive comment on a mock from G4!!! Am I hallucinating!?
See, I'm not a cynical git who hates everything.
Cynical people don't hate EVERYTHING. For example I find faults with Edward Scissorhands but overall it's an OK film.
G4 posted:
jrothwell97 posted:
G4 posted:
Not bad, not bad at all.
*gasp* a positive comment on a mock from G4!!! Am I hallucinating!?
See, I'm not a cynical git who hates everything.
Cynical people don't hate EVERYTHING. For example I find faults with Edward Scissorhands but overall it's an OK film.
NI
But you like Power Rangers and proven yourself time and again to be a complete and utter fool besides. Your general opinion counts no more than a 5 year old's in a discussion on if the UN still serves a purpose in today's world.
And yes, thanks for realising there's faults with things and cynical people don't hate everything, we'd be lost without your insight.
saturdaymorning posted:
Cynical people don't hate EVERYTHING. For example I find faults with Edward Scissorhands but overall it's an OK film.
But you like Power Rangers and proven yourself time and again to be a complete and utter fool besides. Your general opinion counts no more than a 5 year old's in a discussion on if the UN still serves a purpose in today's world.
And yes, thanks for realising there's faults with things and cynical people don't hate everything, we'd be lost without your insight.
BA
There is a whole list (so long I'm going to whip out my bullets) of things wrong with this:
All of these little points make the mock worse and worse. I will score 1/4 because no matter how good the execution gets, the mock will never be good unless the whole idea is revamped.
pad posted:
I guess ITV should take its HD switch as an opportunity to update its presentation.
So we'd have a nice shinier logo. This below image could be used as a sombre ident, but the idents would remain on the current theme of 'alive with yellow'.
http://img128.imageshack.us/img128/9697/stingcb6.jpg
Trailer endboard:
http://img156.imageshack.us/img156/7491/trailerje4.jpg
Improved ECP:
http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/1743/ecpvg9.jpg
So we'd have a nice shinier logo. This below image could be used as a sombre ident, but the idents would remain on the current theme of 'alive with yellow'.
http://img128.imageshack.us/img128/9697/stingcb6.jpg
Trailer endboard:
http://img156.imageshack.us/img156/7491/trailerje4.jpg
Improved ECP:
http://img150.imageshack.us/img150/1743/ecpvg9.jpg
There is a whole list (so long I'm going to whip out my bullets) of things wrong with this:
The itv in the logo is too small
The logo is too rounded and doesn't match up well with the others
The logo is bevelled, so it looks poor
Some of the background of the ECP odesn't contast weel with the text
Nothing sets it apart from an SD channel
The background is boring, meaningless and looks naff
The yellow on yellow imight not show up well
I couldn't see it looking good on TV
All of these little points make the mock worse and worse. I will score 1/4 because no matter how good the execution gets, the mock will never be good unless the whole idea is revamped.
PA
I can happily say I won't take any of your comments on board, purely because you're you.
You are the cretin who actually BOTHERED to put my ITV News mock on your stupid TV to somehow prove the font size was too small - only to be told by everyone else it wasn't.
So your opinion counts for zilch to me personally. Haha!
You are the cretin who actually BOTHERED to put my ITV News mock on your stupid TV to somehow prove the font size was too small - only to be told by everyone else it wasn't.
So your opinion counts for zilch to me personally. Haha!
TI
HD is a slightly different set of rules so you're allowed to do some things that you wouldn't normally be able to (the yellow would come under that heading I suppose).
They look very nice, I quite like whatever you've done to the logo. And billy is evidently grasping at straws..of course there are little things here and there but you are meant to be looking at the big picture after all.
They look very nice, I quite like whatever you've done to the logo. And billy is evidently grasping at straws..of course there are little things here and there but you are meant to be looking at the big picture after all.