TV
Not really sure why this thread exists. I think all of these non-subject specific threads are a bad idea as you can't tell what they're talking about without reading through them.
Why don't we just have one thread on TV Forum called 'TV presentation'!!!
I know I don't have to read it, but I am interested in TV pres in Wales and am probably missing some bits and pieces through not reading the thread.
I think you should split it up a bit. Especially if you're going to be the 4th Mod Jamez!
Well this thread is quite handy for quick comments on Wales Today and HTV News. This thread can get away with little comments that wouldn't really qualify for a thread of their own.
My thoughts exactly. Wales has a unique set up with respect to BBC channels, ITV region, 4th channel, and digital BBC TWO, and so I created a Wales thread.
It's a thread that *I* started, so I'm not sure if appealing to Jamez to do something about it if he becomes moderator is exactly appropriate. If you're expecting Jamez to just do away with threads he doesn't think he understands or follows [as you say you don't], I'm sure you'll be disappointed, as that's not really how it works is it? And especially not one he does understand and participates in.
2W on its own wouldn't be a worthy thread, nor would S4C~ really, and even an HTV News and Wales Today thread fell off the end once. I created this thread on the day of the reopening of the forum for all presentation questions and discussion relating to Wales. As such I think it's one of the oldest threads on the forum, and it's never received a bad comment so far. If there were 6 threads on each of the different things, then I think the forum would become littered with threads amounting to one or two posts only, that would be pointless and irritant. So I don't accept your comment.
I have to say I really don't understand your point. This thread is about presentation in Wales. And that's more or less it -- hence it's very hard to get off topic, and I don't think it's hard to keep up with what's going on -- it moves at a leisurely pace to be honest. I'm sorry if my digression into Ruth Wignall offended you, but I'm a human being with feelings and it's what crossed my mind. Ruth has been discussed before many times and I'm not a robot, just talking about presentation, idents, chairs, astons and 53-page BBC threads all the time -- I happen to think the real people behind the television are also relevant.
Jamez posted:
Moz posted:
Why don't we just have one thread on TV Forum called 'TV presentation'!!!
I know I don't have to read it, but I am interested in TV pres in Wales and am probably missing some bits and pieces through not reading the thread.
I think you should split it up a bit. Especially if you're going to be the 4th Mod Jamez!
Well this thread is quite handy for quick comments on Wales Today and HTV News. This thread can get away with little comments that wouldn't really qualify for a thread of their own.
My thoughts exactly. Wales has a unique set up with respect to BBC channels, ITV region, 4th channel, and digital BBC TWO, and so I created a Wales thread.
It's a thread that *I* started, so I'm not sure if appealing to Jamez to do something about it if he becomes moderator is exactly appropriate. If you're expecting Jamez to just do away with threads he doesn't think he understands or follows [as you say you don't], I'm sure you'll be disappointed, as that's not really how it works is it? And especially not one he does understand and participates in.
2W on its own wouldn't be a worthy thread, nor would S4C~ really, and even an HTV News and Wales Today thread fell off the end once. I created this thread on the day of the reopening of the forum for all presentation questions and discussion relating to Wales. As such I think it's one of the oldest threads on the forum, and it's never received a bad comment so far. If there were 6 threads on each of the different things, then I think the forum would become littered with threads amounting to one or two posts only, that would be pointless and irritant. So I don't accept your comment.
I have to say I really don't understand your point. This thread is about presentation in Wales. And that's more or less it -- hence it's very hard to get off topic, and I don't think it's hard to keep up with what's going on -- it moves at a leisurely pace to be honest. I'm sorry if my digression into Ruth Wignall offended you, but I'm a human being with feelings and it's what crossed my mind. Ruth has been discussed before many times and I'm not a robot, just talking about presentation, idents, chairs, astons and 53-page BBC threads all the time -- I happen to think the real people behind the television are also relevant.