TV Home Forum

BBC HD

(May 2011)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
UK
UKnews
Seem to be some sound problems (crackling) on BBC HD just now - it wasn't evident during HIGMNFY, but that was in stereo unlike A Little Later which is in 5.1 - could the lack of 5.1 on BBC One HD's Doctor Who tonight be related?

What lack of 5.1 on Doctor Who? No problems when I watched it today (Sky+ HD box).
DA
davidhorman
Was that from the BBC One HD showing on Saturday (which didn't have 5.1 according to my setup), or the BBC HD showing on Sunday (which did)?

I'm on Freesat, if that would have made a difference (I assume I would be watching the same stream as a Sky viewer).
JU
jumpinjack
Was that from the BBC One HD showing on Saturday (which didn't have 5.1 according to my setup), or the BBC HD showing on Sunday (which did)?

I'm on Freesat, if that would have made a difference (I assume I would be watching the same stream as a Sky viewer).


Something wrong with your setup Saturday BBC1 Dr. Who was transmitted in 5.1
TG
TG
New problem since the update to DVB-S2, at least on some Sky boxes, is the loss of BBC One HD and BBC HD - just error 25 "No satellite signal is being received".

I've lost them, and by the looks of various forums, so have rather a lot of others...
HA
harshy Founding member
I got it back my retuning it's using some odd parameters which maybe is what's throwing some boxes, it still looks the same to the viewer though no visible improvements Sad
DE
deejay
I had to do a retune of my Humax Foxsat PVR to get BBC One HD and BBC HD back. It seems I'm not the only one with this. Some (non-approved) free-to-air satellite boxes it seems aren't DVB-S2 compliant at all and people are complaining that the BBC only gave days notice of the change. Can't help but feel they shouldn't have much grounds for comaplaint given that they're not using Freesat standard equipment...
NE
Neo
They're going to change to broadcasting BBC HD in 1920x1080 on 13th June (on Freeview HD, Freesat, etc. I think) to allow for 3D Side-by-Side (for Tennis), and then back normal (1440x1080) on 6th July.
Last edited by Neo on 9 June 2011 3:49am - 2 times in total
NG
noggin Founding member
Neo posted:
They're going to change to broadcasting BBC HD in 1920x1080 on 13th June (on Freeview HD, Freesat, etc. I think) to allow for 3D Side-by-Side (for Tennis), and then back normal (1440x1080) on 6th July.


Yep - side-by-side in 1440x1080 would only give 720x1080 resolution for each eye - rather than the 960x1080 you get with 1920x1080. Not unexpected. Presumably they can bump up the bandwith a bit for the duration now they have switched to S2?
TR
trivialmatters
The BBC News article said the 3D tennis would be available to anybody with a 3D able to receive HD broadcasts. Surely that's not true? Can ANY Freeview HD box output 3D pictures?
JO
Joe
I think this is right, yes - because it is the telly set that handles the conversion to a 3D picture (compatible with the right glasses), not the box, which merely sends out a side-by-side image. '3D' packages, like those on Sky, presumably simply allow the viewer access to the dedicated 3D channel which still only outputs a side-by-side image.
01
01tomki
yes, all you will need is a 3D TV, which probably has freeview HD built in
JO
Joe
Presumably a 3D broadcast is 'flagged' as such, similar to how aspect ratios are flagged? Or is it more technical than that?

Newer posts