The Newsroom

BBC News Channel General Discussion

(November 2013)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
CA
Cando
He got some stick, because what he said about having no time to prepare before the 5pm obit broadcast, is incorrect.
You don't forget times and places when news like this broke, and I was producing radio coverage of a football game that day. The PA 'snap' embargo of the death of the QM came on the news wire screen in my studio at 4.16pm. IRN/ITN then confirmed at 4.20. By 4.30, full details of the network obit major story proccedure at 5pm and what to do and which IRN feed to route through the studio mixer.

For an expirenced journalist/broadcast of the calibre of Sisssons, to try a claim he had less than 20 mins from knowing, to being on air is, given the news wires were humming from 4.15 is utter twodge on a grand scale.


AIUI there was some notice given to the main networks that an important statement was coming, but BBC Management did not pass this onto the Newsroom as they were afraid it would leak. Which is why, when it did break, the BBC Newsroom were so unprepared.

They were told in plenty of time. The rumours had been flying around for hours across the media and had plenty of tributes lined up. The biggest problem with the BBC's coverage was that Sissons was a bumbling mess, his interview with Margaret Rhodes was dreadful and was saved from catastrophe on numerous occasions by Jennie Bond. Even in his self serving Autobiography he admits that it wasn't his finest hour. The Burgundy tie was the least of his problems that night. It's always very easy to blame the "management"
bilky asko and London Lite gave kudos
HO
House
Cando posted:
He got some stick, because what he said about having no time to prepare before the 5pm obit broadcast, is incorrect.
You don't forget times and places when news like this broke, and I was producing radio coverage of a football game that day. The PA 'snap' embargo of the death of the QM came on the news wire screen in my studio at 4.16pm. IRN/ITN then confirmed at 4.20. By 4.30, full details of the network obit major story proccedure at 5pm and what to do and which IRN feed to route through the studio mixer.

For an expirenced journalist/broadcast of the calibre of Sisssons, to try a claim he had less than 20 mins from knowing, to being on air is, given the news wires were humming from 4.15 is utter twodge on a grand scale.


AIUI there was some notice given to the main networks that an important statement was coming, but BBC Management did not pass this onto the Newsroom as they were afraid it would leak. Which is why, when it did break, the BBC Newsroom were so unprepared.

They were told in plenty of time. The rumours had been flying around for hours across the media and had plenty of tributes lined up. The biggest problem with the BBC's coverage was that Sissons was a bumbling mess, his interview with Margaret Rhodes was dreadful and was saved from catastrophe on numerous occasions by Jennie Bond. Even in his self serving Autobiography he admits that it wasn't his finest hour. The Burgundy tie was the least of his problems that night. It's always very easy to blame the "management"


Although, arguably, the colour of his tie is something a director, producer or any other member of the team could/should have spotted, and rectified - not Sissons alone. I'm sure occasions like those aren't anyone's finest hour.
SP
Steve in Pudsey
I thought the non black tie was explained away as a policy thing at the time?

On the embargo thing, Jennie Bond may have heard rumours or unofficial tip offs and warned the news editor that an announcement might be imminent, but they wouldn't broadcast anything until they had the ok from the Palace.

An early warning may have allowed them to tentatively start making preparations for obit coverage, check what updates the obit tape might need, get OB units and extra staff on standby etc.
VM
VMPhil
I thought the non black tie was explained away as a policy thing at the time?

Something to do with the BBC thinking audiences didn't want the full obituary treatment for royal figures anymore, ISTR?
WO
Worzel
I thought the non black tie was explained away as a policy thing at the time?

Something to do with the BBC thinking audiences didn't want the full obituary treatment for royal figures anymore, ISTR?


I would assume that had it been a female newsreader delivering the news, there would have been a public outcry because she wasn't wearing a tie at all. Wink
VM
VMPhil
In that great 'Newsflash' documentary from a couple of years ago Mary Nightingale says she was lucky she was wearing a grey suit when the news broke considering the criticism Sissons received, especially as a bulletin had just finished and they had to come straight back on air.

In fact the quote I'm thinking of (about no longer wearing a black tie for royal deaths) comes from the same part of the documentary, by Jennie Bond

https://youtu.be/gFoEC2O9R4U?t=43m56s
JT
jolly turnip
From an outsiders point of view I have always presumed a black tie / subdued outfit is kept by all main newsreaders at the studios in case of such events.
NY
NYTV
From an outsiders point of view I have always presumed a black tie / subdued outfit is kept by all main newsreaders at the studios in case of such events.

IIRC, A former BBC presenter said in their autobiography (Sissons, I think it was) that the BBC made black suits for their presenters for such an occasion, but not many of them are used.
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
Spectacular crash on BBC News Channel feed at start of Victoria Derbyshire programme - including blank screen and BBC Broadcasting House Studio B SPGA colour bars!
RK
Rkolsen
Spectacular crash on BBC News Channel feed at start of Victoria Derbyshire programme - including blank screen and BBC Broadcasting House Studio B SPGA colour bars!

SPGA?
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
*
LL
Larry the Loafer
Considering how technically superior everything is compared to say twenty years ago, it's ironic how they can't manage to put up a breakdown slide, instead leaving their viewers with dead air and driving them away, something every broadcaster can't even bear to think about.

Newer posts