TV Home Forum

Radio Ga Ga!

Silence Is Golden (January 2004)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
Well it probably won't be complete silence, there's bound to be a "nervous" cough or two from the audience as well as the slight flap of paper when they all turn the page in their music sheets... Of course Radio 3's transmission equipment will probably whack up it's volume a bit trying to search for a sound signal! Let's hope they've remembered to remove the backup tape in case it's too quiet!

They should really try it at the Proms this year - It would be amazing to see the Albert Hall in complete silence!

One other thing - how will the audience know when to clap at the end? I doubt they have a big clock counting down until the end of the "song".
MB
MalcyB
I expect the cue to the audience at the end will be when the orchestra all rise and bow.
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
Axctually I don't see any point in applauding them for that particular piece - they'll be doing sod all apart from turning a few blank pages!

But I suppose if they do "sod all" well....
MB
MalcyB
Maybe the audience hold the "piece de resistance" master-card and they acknowledge the piece with silent clapping!
JV
James Vertigan Founding member
Interesting silence! About 2 1/2 minutes into it one of the orchestra played a brief piano note then everyone started coughing and so everyone laughed!

The BBC did well not to let the backup tape kick in! Maybe thats what the orchestra/audience did that for... and again at about 4:30

Err... hang on - it's gone over 4:33! It was 5 minutes 33!

The presenter has just explained that had there been complete silence and the emergency tape had not been disabled the tape would've kicked in after 2 minutes... that's a bit long isn't it? Most stations tapes kick in after 30 seconds or 1 minute of silence!
DV
DVB Cornwall
Can't wait for the TV coverage in a few minutes.
KA
Katherine Founding member
I'm already producing the Funky Monkey Dance Edit for it......
:-(
A former member
James Vertigan posted:
Interesting silence! About 2 1/2 minutes into it one of the orchestra played a brief piano note then everyone started coughing and so everyone laughed!

The BBC did well not to let the backup tape kick in! Maybe thats what the orchestra/audience did that for... and again at about 4:30

The presenter has just explained that had there been complete silence and the emergency tape had not been disabled the tape would've kicked in after 2 minutes... that's a bit long isn't it? Most stations tapes kick in after 30 seconds or 1 minute of silence!


There was an item about this on Front Row on Tuesday. A lot of effort was made to disable the emergency system. All the networks have diffrent durations for the emergency tape to kick in. Radios 3 & 4 have more intended pauses than Radio 1 so the 'kick in' delay is more.

the full item is availiable here:
http://www.bbc.co.uk/radio4/arts/frontrow/ram/2004/frontrow20040113_cage.ram
SL
SteveL
James Vertigan posted:
Most stations tapes kick in after 30 seconds or 1 minute of silence!

Metro Radio's backup system kicks in a lot sooner than that - usually when there's a minute's silence at the start of a football match we get Sean Caldwell yelling "THE BEST MUSIC!" after about 10 seconds.

And the presenter also explained that the actual piece lasted 4'33", and that that didn't include the gaps between movements.
BT
Baroness Trumpington
Larry Scutta posted:
[A lot of effort was made to disable the emergency system.


It's not too tricky. You turn a key in a panel. Remembering to do it is the hazardous part, as Radio 4 found out during a lengthy commemorative silence from St Paul's not so long ago......
JO
Joel
For those of you who "missed" it, it's available at BBC News Online lovely.

Joel.
xxx

Newer posts