The Newsroom

NBC's Tim Russert dies

(June 2008)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
BE
Ben Founding member
I think just telling people he died of a heart attack would suffice. I don't think there is much need for the public at large to know what caused that heart attack, certainly not in such crude terms so soon after the man died.
IT
itsrobert Founding member
Ben posted:
I think just telling people he died of a heart attack would suffice. I don't think there is much need for the public at large to know what caused that heart attack, certainly not in such crude terms so soon after the man died.


I wouldn't say it is 'crude'. It's just biology - many people know about good/bad cholesterol and arterial plaques. How is it any different from saying someone died from a malignant form of cancer? If anything, it's a lesson for us all...
IS
Inspector Sands
itsrobert posted:

The point is that Tim Russert was a well-known and much-loved TV personality in the US who died suddenly after no apparent illness. It's only natural for people to be curious as to how he dropped dead at work.


People are curious about many things, doesn't mean that they've got the right to know.

I don't know what the hypocratic position is in the US, but I doubt a doctor here would be able to come out and give so much detail
CO
Connews
People are more detailed with cancer and diseases, why not heart conditions? People with brain tumours don't die of "headache."
JO
Jonathan
Connews posted:
People are more detailed with cancer and diseases, why not heart conditions? People with brain tumours don't die of "headache."

The morbid and inappropriate description given by that doctor removed any kind of sentimentality and respect from the death of a professional.
IT
itsrobert Founding member
I think you guys are over-reacting. I studied A-Level Biology and those phrases were commonplace. I certainly wouldn't call them 'crude' or 'morbid'. Most of the general public are aware of thrombosis, plaques, arteries, cancer, tumour etc. We're not living in the 1800s for goodness sake!

Newer posts