The Newsroom

The 'Victoria Derbyshire' Programme

Victoria Derbyshire's new daytime show... (January 2015)

This site closed in March 2021 and is now a read-only archive
RK
Rkolsen
DTV posted:
Nice to see BBC News giving the VDP a very important 'exclusive' interview. The Shaker Aamer interview was done by Victoria Derbyshire and she now seems to be a 'senior anchor' at BBC.

Lots of promos or mentions of tomorrows programme, during the credits of The Hunt and also during tonights Ten, they both mentioned the full interview being shown tomorrow.


This is possibly the biggest issue I have with the VD programme, sometimes it is human interest other times it tries to be hardhitting. It is a programme without any raison d'etre. Sometimes they'll go all Newsnighty, sometime they'll do a Question Time episode and sometimes they'll try and emulate ITV daytime - why don't they pick a genre and stick to it. Sometimes they'll spend episodes devoted to politics - see Labour Leadership contest - other days they won't mention it all. The very fact that they can't make up their minds what kind of a show it is, is presumably why they need so many pieces of furniture - a sofa for the human interest, lounge chairs for the more serious interviews, bar furniture for when they're doing discussion pieces, a touchscreen for when they're doing analysis.

Why we need this programme is another question - all its 'areas of coverage' are adequately covered elsewhere. Serious interviews and analysis are covered well by Newsnight, even if nobody is watching (although nobody is still higher than the VD ratings); Question Time episodes are covered well by I forget, oh yeah Question Time; Human interest is covered exceptionally well by ITV and to a lesser extent The One Show; Political News is covered by the Daily Politics and Breaking News used to be well reported between 0915 and 1100 by the BBC News Channel - but unfortunately the head of BBC News seemingly believes that there exists something that covers the remit of a rolling news channel better than rolling news. This interview would be very well suited to Newsnight, but then I suppose BBC Manager logic dictates its better to sacrifice a fledgling 35 year old national institution to help prop up a fledgling and hard to justify 8 month old pile of sh*te than it is to axe a programme less than a year after its inception because there is no point in there being a Newsnight/Question Time/One Show/This Morning/Daily Politics/Rolling News hybrid.


Sounds like it's the British equivalent of Oprah but with much much much lower ratings.
MA
Markymark


Sounds like it's the British equivalent of Oprah but with much much much lower ratings.


To be fair, I've not watched either show (why would I ?) but I suspect what you say is akin to comparing a crop spraying aeroplane with a Boeing 747.
RK
Rkolsen


Sounds like it's the British equivalent of Oprah but with much much much lower ratings.


To be fair, I've not watched either show (why would I ?) but I suspect what you say is akin to comparing a crop spraying aeroplane with a Boeing 747.

Yes, where Oprah did serious interviews she also did light harder stuff based on what was going on at the time. But Oprah was the queen of daytime TV for most of her reign with the highest ratings. Where as from what I heard VD isn't doing that great in the ratings.
NG
noggin Founding member

Sounds like it's the British equivalent of Oprah but with much much much lower ratings.


No - nothing like Oprah at all really. It's much more like a US 'personality-led' cable news show. It's a news show with no studio audience (apart from occasional 'speak your brains' people sat on stools) and isn't celebrity-interview based.
Stuart, London Lite and Cando gave kudos
LL
London Lite Founding member
The first of the 'best of' the VDP is on Monday at 10.30am. NC is on from 0900-1030 instead, while BBC2 has a film.
MA
Marcus Founding member
The first of the 'best of' the VDP is on Monday at 10.30am. NC is on from 0900-1030 instead, while BBC2 has a film.


What are they putting on at 10.31?
HB
HarryB
Special VDP today dedicated to the rocket launch with a ceiling replacement Wink

*
watchingtv and BenMacDonald gave kudos
DT
DTV
Special VDP today dedicated to the rocket launch with a ceiling replacement Wink

*


I had no idea the BBC graphics team had Paint on their systems.

28 days later

HB
HarryB
New way of showing a 'title' to the main story on todays show.
*
RK
Rkolsen
New way of showing a 'title' to the main story on todays show.
*

I know E has an led screen in front of their desk but does B? The quality of the text makes me think it's augmented.
CH
chris
New way of showing a 'title' to the main story on todays show.
*

I know E has an led screen in front of their desk but does B? The quality of the text makes me think it's augmented.


Looks like a cheap on-screen graphic to me. The majority of the VD graphics look naff.
ST
Stuart
Since when has there been a plastic screen underneath the LED display?

I've never noticed that before. Is it an H&S measure to stop people 'accidentally' limbo dancing underneath it? Shocked

Newer posts